Here’s a letter (from a ‘transwoman’ I haven’t seen yet … and I’m waiting … and waiting …

I don’t know what I was thinking.  No, that’s not true.  I do know what I was thinking.  I was thinking I could be a gentler person, free of all that macho shit.  I thought I could indulge my feminine side without shame (and yes, perhaps with praise).  I thought I could finally be the person I want to be.

I neglected to consider the behavior of others.  The way they constrain the person I am.

How could I have been so stupid?  It was the behavior of others, of men, that constrained me before, preventing me from being that gentler person, insisting I ‘man up’, calling me a wimp, and worse, threatening to hurt me if I didn’t join their various herds, their various brutalities …

But now, now that I’m a woman—

I’m interrupted.  All the time.  I can’t finish one damned sentence before—  At first I called them on it: Excuse me, I was talking.  Bitch.  Cunt.

Often it’s not even an interruption: people, men, just speak over me like I’m not even there, let alone saying something.

I’ve noticed I’m using shorter sentences now, speaking more quickly, to say what I want to say before someone shuts me down.  I used to speak in whole paragraphs.

My queries, to everyone, about anything, go unanswered more often than not.

And when they are answered, it takes weeks.

And the replies are brief.  As if I’m not worth their time.  I have to ask again and again until I have all the information I need.  I used to be offered information without even having to ask for it.

I’m challenged on every damn thing.  All day.  Every day.  Even on my most uncontroversial utterances, I’m questioned: Are you sure?  How do you know that?

I’ve noticed I’m starting to question myself.  Maybe I don’t know what I thought I knew.

Even outside work, not only am I challenged and questioned all the time, I get unsolicited advice.  All the time.  As if I know nothing.  About anything.  It gets very tiresome.  And, of course, the implied insult is very … angering.

No one ever asks for my opinion.

No matter how good my arguments, no matter how much supporting evidence I present, I have no influence whatsoever.  Over anything.

I have to prove myself over and over and over and over.  Reputation doesn’t exist for women except as a bitch or a slut.  So I can never let my reputation for good work precede me; I can never rest on my record: in every situation, I have to start over, proving my competence.  It used to be … assumed.  That I was competent.

Maybe I’m not as good as I thought.

I’ve received fewer promotions.  What am I saying, I’ve received no promotions.

When I publicize my achievements, I’m arrogant, I’m bragging.  Not to mention disbelieved.

When I ask for a raise, I’m uppity.  And so for sure no raise is forthcoming.

I swear I was doing the same quality of work as I used to, all those years.

And then when I did fuck up one day, I was fired.  Just like that.  No second chance, no allowances made for …anything.

And then, I was flabbergasted at the interviews I was not granted.  Even for positions well below my qualifications and experience.  Often my application wasn’t even acknowledged.

The jobs I’ve had to accept pay less than the jobs I had before.  In fact, I refused the first three offers because the pay was so insulting.  Then I realized … that was as good as it was going to get.

Eventually I had to get a job as a waitress.  Yes, me!  A waitress!  And it wasn’t enough that I was punctual and pleasant.  I had to flirt to get tips, and since they’re allowed to pay waitresses less than the minimum wage, I had to get tips if I was to make rent.  It’s so demeaning.  I feel like a prostitute trainee.  And the uniform.  Tight top, short skirt, high heels.  For eight or ten hours.

And it was just part-time. So no sick days.  No medical.  No dental.  No pension.

I had to sell my condo and move into a crappy apartment.

And what fresh hell, getting the super to replace the fridge, to fix the plumbing, anything—  He always puts me at the bottom of the list and acts like he’s doing me a favour.  It’s his fucking job!  I am, essentially, paying him to do it!

I’ve been called rude so many times.  And I swear, I’m not acting any differently.  But it’s like I’m expected to be over the top nice all the time, smiling at everyone …

I can’t just ask for what I want anymore.  That’s considered rude.

I can’t just say, plainly and directly, what I think anymore.  That’s considered rude.

I’m expected to volunteer for everything, to ‘help out’, do this, do that.  For free.  Like I don’t need money to support myself?

Men accuse me of ignoring them.  They make it sound like a reprimand.

They expect me to look after them, as if they are entitled to my time and attention.

Apparently I’m supposed to defer to, well, everyone.  No matter what’s at stake.  Apparently my primary objective in life now is not to hurt others.  Others’ feelings.

When I happen to be beside a man, the other person always acknowledges him first.  Sometimes not ever getting around to acknowledging me.

My presence, my existence, is tolerated.  At best.

And when I happen to be on my own …

There is endless commentary about how I look.  At first, I enjoyed it, but after a while, it becomes clear that that’s all anyone cares about.  It’s insulting.

And the touching.  Again, at first I enjoyed it, but then, well, it was just all the time.  Often for no discernible reason.  When a man will shake another man’s hand, that same man puts his arm around me, pulling me close, giving me a squeeze.  What’s up with that?

But heaven forbid I ask him to remove his arm.  One man became so apoplectic, I thought he was going to hit me.

Even online.  I don’t want to be too graphic here, but I’ve received rape and death threats.  They’ve been very explicit, very detailed.  And they’ve been issued simply because I disagreed with a guy.  And said so.

Even when I don’t say anything that might—  It seems like men are either coming on to me or insulting me.  It’s either one or the other.

And the insults are always sexual.  Bitch, cow, cunt— Subordination by sexualization.

It’s like—  I thought I was getting away from the fighting.  But now, it’s like I have to fight for everything: acknowledgement, respect, opportunity, autonomy, dignity … Everything I used to take for granted.

I didn’t use to have to try so hard to be taken seriously.

I didn’t use to have to try so hard at anything, really.

I’m ashamed to say, I had no idea what women have had to endure …

I didn’t know anything about sexism.  Not really.  Most men don’t.  In fact, I’ll bet most men understand less about sexism than white people understand about racism.

After all, this is a meritocracy.  So any advantage I had over women was due to my respective choices, my relative competence.  I thought.

When the novelty wore off, I realized I’d traded my first-class seat on a plane for a second-class  seat on the bus.  (Too late I realized that Martine Rothblatt and Caitlyn Jenner were rich and famous.  Even before.  That Laverne Cox worked in the entertainment industry.  And so had an agent.)

I had no idea I was voluntarily becoming a member of the sexed subordinate class.  No wonder twice as many transwomen as transmen commit suicide.  On top of everything else, we’re broadsided by a sudden and almost complete disenfranchisement.

I read that thing about Martin and Nicole changing names on their emails.  After a week of being treated like Nicole, Martin said, “It sucked”.  And after a week of being treated like Martin, Nicole said she had one of the easiest weeks of her professional life.  I get that now.  I really get it.  And I have to say, I’m not looking forward to this being the rest of my life. Not just a week of Monday to Friday, nine to five.  But before and after work as well.  And on the weekend.  And for not just a week, but for a month.  A year.  Ten years.  Twenty.  Forty.  Your whole fucking life, every minute of every damned day, from the time you get up to the time you finally fall asleep, being ignored or dismissed, being doubted, being demeaned and humiliated …

 

McSweeney’s List about the Birth Rate – brilliantly hilarious

Check it out!

https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/americas-op-ed-columnists-brainstorm-future-headlines-about-the-birth-rate

experiences reported in Complaint, Sara Ahmed

“I took an off-the-record grievance pay-out (not massive) and a much-reduced pension to get out of academia two years ago after an unremitting fifteen years of sexist (and disablist) bullying.   … I had to sign a gagging clause when I got my grievance pay-out which—as I’m sure you are aware—is how universities typically try to  cover up the sexism that is rampant within them.” p10

“Furious with administrators for protecting their institutional reputations instead of their students’ rights, survivors bypassed obstructionist deans, invented new strategies of collaboration, taught themselves Title IX, and with unprecedented clout brought over two hundred universities under federal investigation.” p23

“It took us forever to try and find the complaints procedure PDF on the database. We knew it existed but it was like a mythical golden egg, we just couldn’t find it.  And when we did, it was so big that even two PhD students spent weeks trying to get through the small print, to find out what the complaint process was.”  p31

“I am the one who has to arrange all this information and send it to different people because they are just not talking to each other.  I had to file the forms in order to get the Human Resources records; I had to do all the Freedom of Information requests.  It was on me to do all of this work, which raises the question of why have Human Resources officers at all because I am literally doing their job.”  p35-36

“[an academic who made use of multiple policies in putting together a complaint about plagiarism] … the minute you try to enact policy that you are told when you are hired to be the vanguards of, to protect the quality of education and work at the university  … you become the person to be investigated.” p43

 

[And that’s just the Introduction and first chapter.]

Home for Old Hags

Struck by arthritis and its attendant mobility issues, the most worrisome being an increased risk of falling while walking in the forest or on her way down to the water, it hit her: her life would be shorter than most because she’d rather kill herself than live in a so-called retirement village.

It was bad enough to live in a regular neighborhood.  She’d been called a cunt and a bitch.  She’d been dismissed and patronized.  She’d been treated like a teenager because she wasn’t married with kids.  She’d been treated like an outsider, never invited over, because she was solo.

Then one day, after she’d watched Quartet, about a home for old musicians, she thought yeah, maybe, if she could find a home for old academics and artists … aha!  A home for old feminists!

She spent a day figuring out how to tap into crowd funding.

Almost immediately, a few women with business experience stepped forward.  Lunged forward, actually.  Leapt into the air and somersaulted before landing.

They discussed ideas, options, plans, then settled on the perfect location.  And found it.  A large flat acreage, on a small lake, with a woodsy area out back.

Then started hiring.  Landscapers, architects, carpenters, electricians, plumbers … All women.  And all had read Perez.  Many times.  So the apartments were built for people who were, on average, 5’2″.  Counter heights, cupboard heights, cupboard depths …

And for people who were, on average, 75 years of age.  Grab bars, step-in tubs …

One- and two-bedroom apartments.  Some with private kitchens.  A communal kitchen for those without.

A couple cafes for those who were used to living in the city.  Though many of them were now craving quiet and solitude.  And those who had lived with quiet and solitude craved companionship every now and then.

A library.  A movie room.

They bought a pontoon boat that seated six, as well as a few kayaks for those still able.

Several paths were established through the woods, one paved for those on chairs, one with a handrail from tree to tree, for the visually-challenged and balance-challenged, both with benches for resting along the way…

They advertised for maintenance staff, administrative staff, nursing staff, kitchen staff, drivers, general assistants.  And were flooded with applications.  All women, all ages, all wanting to work in a place where they’d never see a man, never have to deal with a man.

And more, all fully aware of the benefits of interacting with old feminists.  Women who had been on the fronts, literally, of getting access to contraception, and abortion, and bank accounts, and driver’s licences, and deeds to land … and not needing your husband’s permission, for anything …

Some of the young women were startled.  You couldn’t own property?  Why not?  You couldn’t even apply to go to Harvard—until 1999?  Are you fucking kidding me?

The old women sighed.  What are they teaching you these days?

What they themselves had been taught, they realized.  Men’s history.  Only men’s history.   Always men’s history.

A few men applied, but they almost always hired a woman.  Because, funny thing, the best applicant was always a woman.

The first time they had to hire a man, they—well, they could fill a book with what they might’ve said to him.  In fact, a few of them had.  Which was why they were silent now.  Why their eyes just sort of glazed over now.  Why they just ignored him now.  Completely.

He couldn’t handle it.  The lack of attention.  It was like he didn’t matter.  At all.  And he couldn’t bear it.  He left.

And they looked at each other.  Stunned.  Busily rewriting their pasts.

No, someone finally spoke up.  The one first to reach the end of that alternate universe.  They were killing us.  We couldn’t’ve just ignored them.

Nods.  All round.

And then sighs.

The second time they hired a man, several of the women hid his tools.  Several times.  They failed to give him clear instructions.  It took him a whole week for a two-day job.   They pointed this out to him, then paid him 77 cents on the dollar.

Enraged, he spread the word.

They cheered.

Soon another Home opened.  And another.  Their landscapers, carpenters, plumbers, and electricians had to hire apprentices.  And found them.  Easily.

Administrative, health, and food services had long dominated by women, so there were no staffing problems there.

Of course many of the residents weren’t quite ready to give up.  To give it up.  They found that after a year of respite?  refreshment? they were ready to resume their political activism.

Women had always been good at organizing.  Which was why management dominated by men had been such a disaster.  It was women who kept track of the kids’ field trips, and dentist appointments, and doctors’ appointments, and music lessons, and after-school practices.  Women even kept their bosses organized.  Acknowledgement of which would have most certainly challenged the power structure.  Nine to Five was one of the more popular movies in their collection.

And so.  Bag ladies became bomb squads.  Sports stadiums were their first targets.  Because really, 5 billion dollars to build a place for adult males to play with balls in public?  Boys will be boys, well into adulthood if they are not stopped and reprimanded for their immaturity.

How many hospitals and schools could be built with the money?  How many doctors and teachers could be hired?  And paid commensurate to their value?

Blackmail became rampant.  It’s amazing how much an old woman fussing in the corner of a room can record.  Private offices, executive suites, boardrooms, hotel lobbies.

Contraception and abortion became available again.  Money was found to process the thousands of rape kits just sitting in evidence lockers.  Judges were appointed to hear the appeals of the many women incarcerated for, essentially, self-defence.  So many decisions were reversed for no apparent a reason.  So many orders countermanded.

from No Logo, Naomi Klein

“… many of today’s best-known manufacturers no longer produce products and advertise them, but rather buy products and ‘brand’ them …” p5

“[T]his corporate obsession with brand identity is waging a war on public and individual space; on public institutions such as schools, on youthful identities, on the concept of nationality, and on the possibilities for unmarketed space.” p5

“[M]edia and retail companies have inflated to such bloated proportions that simple decisions about what items to stock in a store or what kind of cultural product to commission … now have enormous consequences; those who make these choices have the power to reengineer the cultural landscape.” p165

“Streets are public spaces, adbusters argue, and since most residents can’t afford to counter corporate messages by purchasing their own ads, they should have the right to talk back to images they never asked to see.” p280

“The earth is not dying, it is being killed.  And those that are killing it have names and addresses.”  Utah Phillips (quoted by Klein on p325)

“… contest the authority of corporations to govern” p325  (Indeed.  They weren’t elected.)

“… children in Indonesia and China [are] working in virtual slavery ‘so that children in America can put frilly dresses on America’s favorite doll'” p328

“If Wal-Mart [has] the power to lower prices, alter CD covers, and influence magazine content, [does] it not also have the power to demand and enforce ethical labor standards from its suppliers?” p239

“Disney CEO Michael Eisner earns $9,783 an hour while a Haitian worker ears 28 cents an hou; it would take a Haitian worker 16.8 years to earn Eisner’s hourly income; the $181 million in stock options Eisner exercised in 1996 is enough to take care of his 19,000 Haitian workers and their families for fourteen years.” p352

“Please use your liberty to promote ours.” Aung San Suu Kyi (quoted by Klein on p403)

Janelle Shane’s You Look Like a Thing and I Love You

a few bits from Janelle Shane’s You Look Like a Thing and I Love You

“Researchers have discovered that something as seemingly insignificant a a small sticker can make an image recognition AI think a gun is a toaster …” p4

And vice versa, I presume.  Well, that’s not alarming at all.

“A team at Stanford University once trained an AI to tell the difference between pictures of healthy skin and pictures of skin cancer.  After the researchers trained their AI, however, they discovered that they had inadvertently trained [it to be] a ruler detector instead—many of the tumors in their training data had been photographed next to rulers for scale.” p23

So when your GP asks your permission to use AI assistance … just say no.

“If you give a job-candidate-screening AI biased data to learn from (which you almost certainly did, unless you did a lot of work to scrub bias from the data), then you also give it a convenient shortcut to improve its accuracy at predicting the ‘best’ candidate: prefer white men.” p26-27

Yeah.  Garbage in, garbage out.

“AI has the approximate brainpower of a worm.”

“AI does not really understand the problem you want it to solve.”

“AI will take the path of least resistance.”

 

 

 

“What Does it Mean to Work Under Algorithmic Eyes?”

“We should not take computer scientists at their word that the paradigms for human emotions they have developed… can produce ground truth about human emotions.”

Part of the reason is that machines are biased. Women, older employees, neurodiverse workers, and people of color are far more likely to be misread and mismeasured. What the algorithm flags as “disengagement” may simply be fatigue, cultural difference, or, god forbid, a moment of quiet reflection. Yet those misreadings can influence performance reviews, promotions, and layoffs.”

Yeah.  Computer scientists are in waaaaay over their heads on most AI applications.

Suppose that worldwide …

Suppose that worldwide, women flood the military, soon comprising, say, 40% of the ranks (which will be perceived by men as a majority) (go figure).

Suppose then, as happened when women flooded the ranks of bank tellers, secretaries, and teachers, being a soldier became devalued, losing its prestige, its glory, its funding, its media coverage.

And when being a soldier has about as much appeal as being a waitress … the end of war?

some funny bits from Tim Dorsey’s The Maltese Iguana

“I don’t need to read anything to know what I’m talking about!” / “In one sentence you’ve just summed up everything wrong wtih our country today!”  p152

“A few short years ago, we could look at a drinking glass and agree it was filled to the midpoint with water, then argue about what it meant.  But today?  Good lord!  We all look at the same glass now, and it’s either A: half-full, or B: a squirrel.”  p153

“Entertainment,” said a smiling Serge.  “I love watching when assholes hit a wall.  their brains aren’t wired for anything that can’t be solved with shittiness.”  p214

“After all, a woman was being savagely attacked …  Something needed to be done.  So everyone swung into action and turned on their cell phone cameras.”  p226

“So,” said Serge.  “What do you like in a man?” / “Absence.”  p260

 

Suppose two married women …

Suppose two married women get jobs outside the home at the same time, forcing their husbands to hire someone to do the cooking, cleaning, and childcare.  Ten hours/day, 5 days/week, at $20/hr.  It’s a lot to afford, but the men have so-called ‘breadwinner’ salaries.

Suppose it turns out that Emma is hired by Alyssa’s husband (on Alyssa’s recommendation) and Alyssa is hired by Emma’s husband (on Emma’s recommendation).

And they’re both really enjoying their evenings off and their $52,000/yr incomes.